Skip to main content

Be Social

Home

LEGALUPDATES.COM

Trusted Resources
X
  • Home
  • OUR TEAM
  • JOBs/Classifieds
  • Training Portal

User account menu

  • Login
  • Search

Editorials

Using the Wrong Pronoun at Trial and Prosecutorial Misconduct (Special Attention Prosecutors)

Robert Phillips
29 Nov 2022
CAE00018

By Robert Phillips, Deputy District Attorney (Ret).

A prosecutor’s failure to use the pronoun with which a defendant chooses to identify (i.e., “misgendering”) constitutes prosecutorial misconduct.

“Misgendering:” The word of the day, particularly for prosecutors in trial.  This word is defined by Merriman-Webster as the practice of “identify(ing) the gender of a person, such as a transsexual or transgender person, incorrectly, as by using an incorrect label or pronoun.”  “Misgendering” is further defined by the First District Court of Appeal (Div. 3) in the recent case of People v. Zarazua (Nov. 21, 2022) __ Cal.App.5th __, at fn. 1 [2022 Cal.App. LEXIS 956], as “the assignment of a gender with which a party does not identify, through the misuse of gendered pronouns, titles, names, and honorifics,” citing as its source 109 Cal. L. Rev. 2227, 2232, authored by Chan Tov McNamarch, and entitled “Misgendering.” 

In Zarazua, Ms. Mareza Zarazua was a woman in April, 2019, when she fled from police as they tried to stop her for the simple traffic offense of not having a rear license plate.  After a 15-minute pursuit, she crashed into some bushes and, after a brief foot chase, was arrested.  Turns out her license had been suspended.  Charged in state court with a number of traffic offenses, she showed up for trial in July, 2020 (some 15 months later) identifying herself as a male—Mr. Zarazua—having decided that “she” would rather be a “he.”  The Court does not mention whether any medicinal or surgical procedures accompanied this decision, and is apparently irrelevant to one’s decision to simply choose his (or her) gender even if that decision does not correspond with his (or her) current plumbing.  At any rate, the prosecutor in Zarazua had a hard time accepting this unexpected turn of events, continually referring to Mareza Zarazua as “she” instead of “he” despite numerous objections by the defense attorney and corresponding admonishments by the trial court judge.  Upon Zarazua being convicted on all counts, defense counsel’s motion for mistrial was denied.  Defendant appealed.   

On appeal, the First District Court of Appeal affirmed. But in so holding, the Court presumed that such a blatant “misgendering” on the part of the prosecutor (despite his denial that it was done intentionally) constituted prosecutorial misconduct. However, the Court held that such misconduct was harmless error given the strength of the evidence of Zarazua’s guilt.  Despite upholding Zarazua’s conviction, the Court issued a stern warning to all prosecutors as well as trial court judges.  Specifically, the Court “emphasize(d) that (they) do not condone the prosecutor’s repeated misgendering of Zarazua.  Moreover, (the Court) note(d) (that) trial courts have an obligation to ensure litigants and attorneys are treated with respect, courtesy, and dignity—including the use of preferred pronouns. When court proceedings fall short of that, (trial court) judges should take affirmative steps to address the issue.”  Acknowledging that in this particular case the prosecutor’s failure to use the masculine pronoun was not prejudicial, the Court warned that “there may be instances when misgendering is so overt, malicious, and calculating that it infects the trial with such unfairness as to make the conviction a denial of due process.”

So be forewarned:  Whatever your personal opinion might be as to the ability (legal or political) of a person to merely choose the sex with which he or she may choose to identify, you still must respect that decision and conduct yourself in the courtroom accordingly. Welcome to the 21st century.

Read More

P.O.S.T. Certified Law Enforcement recommended by Legal Updates!

TOP Rated training

PETALUMA POLICE DEPARTMENT IS SEEKING LATERAL OFFICERS

PETALUMA PD

TEHEMA COUNTY IS HIRING FOR DEPUTY SHERIFF AND CORRECTIONAL OFFICERS

 

TehemaDS

 

Home

LEGALUPDATES.COM

Trusted Resources

LEGALUPDATES.COM
1968 S. Coast Highway
Laguna Beach, CA 92651

(877) 266-4003

info@legalupdates.com

Contact Us/Help

Reading Corner

  • Prior Issues
  • Prior Cases
  • Special Updates
  • Bulletins
  • Editorials
  • Memorials
  • FAQs
  • Agency List

Be Social

Resources

  • Donate/Support us
  • Advertise with us
  • Classifieds
  • Honorary Supporters
  • Our Plans
  • White List Us
  • Helpful Links
  • Testimonials

all rights reserved © Copyright protected | legalupdates.com® u.s.r. 6,260.924   | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer & Terms of Use                                                     
Click here to provide Feedback                           

 

  • Home
  • OUR TEAM
  • JOBs/Classifieds
  • Training Portal
  • Login
  • Search

Already have an account? Login Here

Sign up now for free access to this content

Enter your details below and stay ahead of the curve.

We need a little information about you to approve your subscription. We take your privacy seriously. Don’t worry we never share your information with anyone.

Notifications
CAPTCHA

This is to verify you are human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

We take your privacy seriously. As detailed in our Privacy Policy, we do not share your information with anyone. You will be able to update your communication preferences at any time. Please contact Legal Updates if you have any questions or need any assistance.

Login here to access the content

Forgot Password?
We take your privacy seriously. As detailed in our Privacy Policy, we do not share your information with anyone. You will be able to update your communication preferences at any time. Please contact Legal Updates if you have any questions or need any assistance.

We hope you have enjoyed your free trial Professional Membership subscription to Legal Updates. We invite you to continue to receive all our services by upgrading from our Basic to our Professional Membership. You can find a summary of all our plan benefits below. As always, we guarantee full satisfaction and will refund 100% of your payment if you are not satisfied.

Membership Plans

100% SATISFACTION GUARANTEE!

Plan Comparision

BASIC MEMBERSHIP
Complimentary
Limited Access
We still appreciate you!
PROFESSIONAL MEMBERSHIP
Full Unlimited Access
$15.00/mo ($180.00/year)
Sale! Only $7.50/ mo. ($90.00/year)
Access to our Website
Access to our Website
Receive Updates and Case Alerts
Receive Updates and Case Alerts
Access our library of prior issues and special updates
Access our library of prior issues and special updates
Search Capability
Search Capability
Ability to post comments
Ability to post comments
Print/download/save material from our site
Print/download/save material from our site
Direct access to our authors
Direct access to our authors
Annual Statutes and Changes in the law update (100+ pages)
Annual Statutes and Changes in the law update (100+ pages)
Annual Miranda Update
Annual Miranda Update
Annual Search & Seizure and Fourth Amendment Update (1000+ pages) Our most comprehensive and popular update! A must have for Judges, prosecutors, and police supervisors
Annual Search & Seizure and Fourth Amendment Update (1000+ pages) Our most comprehensive and popular update! A must have for Judges, prosecutors, and police supervisors
Annual Professional Training Certificate (12 Hours of training in legal updates)*
Annual Professional Training Certificate (12 Hours of training in legal updates)*
KEEP CURRENT PLAN

NEWSLETTER

Enter your email and would like to subscribe to our monthly updates.

Stay informed - subscribe to our newsletter.
CAPTCHA

This is to verify you are human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.