Skip to main content

Be Social

Home

LEGALUPDATES.COM

Trusted Resources
X
  • Home
  • OUR TEAM
  • JOBs/Classifieds
  • Training Portal

User account menu

  • Login
  • Search

bulletins

Second Amendment Update: Can You Purchase Guns for Someone Else? Can You Lie about That on Forms?

Robert Phillips
February 01, 2025
CAB10025

Defendant Gail Manney has a son, Razaaq, who is a convicted felon. As such, Razaaq is precluded by federal law from owning or possessing a firearm. (18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1).) On April 21, 2021, Manney went to a gun store, a “federal firearms licensee” in Reno, Nev., and arranged to purchase seven firearms. While Manney was in the store checking out the guns, the store clerk noticed that she was continually on her cellphone, talking to someone while taking photographs of the various guns. Upon selecting the guns she wanted, Manney signed an ATF Form 4473 for each firearm, certifying that she was the actual purchaser of the firearms. It was arranged that she would pick them up at a later time in order to give the store the time needed to complete the necessary federal background check before turning the guns over to her.

In the meantime, suspecting that Manney was purchasing the firearms for someone else as a “straw purchaser,” the clerk contacted the local ATF office. An ATF special agent arranged to be present when Manney returned to pick up her guns. After Manney paid for the guns, the special agent contacted her and asked her who she purchased the guns for. Manney said she bought them for herself. Upon a consensual search of her cellphone, however, the agent found numerous incriminating WhatsApp messages between Manney and her son, discussing the firearms purchase.

Convicted in federal court of making false statements on ATF Form 4473 pursuant to 18 U.S.C. §§ 922(a)(6) and 924(a)(2), Manney appealed. On appeal, she argued that these statutes violated the Second Amendment. The issue, therefore, was whether making it a criminal act to lie on the federal ATF Form 4473 survived the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in New York Rifle and Pistol Assn Inc. v. Bruen (2022) 597 U.S. 1. In Bruen, the Supreme Court articulated the proper framework for analyzing Second Amendment challenges. Per Bruen: “When the Second Amendment’s plain text covers an individual’s conduct, the Constitution presumptively protects that conduct.” “The government must then justify its regulation by demonstrating that it is consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.” “Only then may a court conclude that the individual’s conduct falls outside the Second Amendment’s unqualified command.” (Id., at page 24)

Ultimately, the Ninth Circuit ruled in United States v. Manney (9th Cir. Aug. 19, 2024) 114 F.4th 1048, that lying on a federal document is not protected by the Second Amendment. As noted by the court: “The statute did not prohibit Manney from possessing firearms as evidenced by her ability to purchase a firearm shortly before her interaction with (the special) agent...Nor did it prohibit Manney from (later) transferring those firearms to another individual. All the statute did was prohibit Manney from lying about who the actual purchaser was.

Because the Second Amendment does not protect an individual’s false statements, the conduct § 922(a)(6) regulates falls outside the scope of the Second Amendment’s plain text.” The court also held that it is irrelevant whether the “felon-in-possession” statute (18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1)), which Razaaq would have been guilty of had his mother given him the guns, is constitutional. This issue is currently before the Ninth Circuit in United States v. Duarte (9th Cir. May 9, 2024) 101 F.4th 657; subsequently vacated for an en banc review. As a result, the court found 18 U.S.C. §§ 922(a)(6) and 924(a)(2) to be constitutional and not subverted by the Bruen test.

Interestingly enough, it is not a violation of federal law to be a straw purchaser. (See Abramski v. United States (June 16, 2014) 573 U.S. 169, at pgs. 178-189.) It is also not illegal to later give the guns to another even though the one who receives them is a felon, rendering the recipient guilty of being a “felon in possession.” The crime is the making of a false statement on the federal forms by which the purchaser lies about who is actually purchasing the firearms. This being the case, Gail Manney was properly convicted for lying on the forms she filled out to purchase the guns for her son.


Read More

 

 

FVPD

lupc

HU

 

TOP Rated training

 

https://www.rlslawyers.com/

 

 

 

The information you are viewing is copyrighted and intended exclusively for the use of . Reproduction, forwarding, or any form of distribution of this information are explicitly prohibited and constitute a violation of federal and state trademark laws.

If you wish to distribute this information, please contact us to inquire about obtaining a licensing agreement. If you hold a full agency license, you may distribute this document among your agency members.

I certify under penalty of perjury that I will not share or distribute this document with any other person.

Please provide your consent by clicking on the checkbox to agree not to share the content of this material.

DOWNLOAD

Home

LEGALUPDATES.COM

Trusted Resources

LEGALUPDATES.COM
1968 S. Coast Highway
Laguna Beach, CA 92651

(877) 266-4003

CONTACT US

Reading Corner

  • Prior Issues
  • Prior Cases
  • Special Updates
  • Bulletins
  • Editorials
  • Memorials
  • FAQs
  • Agency List

Be Social

Resources

  • Configure block
  • Edit menu
  • Advertise with us
  • Classifieds
  • Honorary Supporters
  • Our Plans
  • White List Us
  • Helpful Links
  • Testimonials

all rights reserved © Copyright protected | legalupdates.com® u.s.r. 6,260.924 | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer & Terms of Use
Click here to provide Feedback

  • Home
  • OUR TEAM
  • JOBs/Classifieds
  • Training Portal
  • Login
  • Search

Login here to access the content

Forgot Password?
We take your privacy seriously. As detailed in our Privacy Policy, we do not share your information with anyone. You will be able to update your communication preferences at any time. Please contact Legal Updates if you have any questions or need any assistance.

 

Immediate “real-time” law updates to stay current in the law and prevail in your cases. Our professional plan provides full access to “must have” resources for Law Enforcement Officers, Attorneys, Judicial Officers and students of law.

Our Professional plan not only keeps you current, but provides you with mandatory continuing education credits you must have to remain active in your profession. We are certified by the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (P.O.S.T.) and the California State Bar to provide Legal Updates training. We are 100% online and self-paced.

Plan Comparision

BASIC MEMBERSHIP
Complimentary
Limited Access
We still appreciate you!
PROFESSIONAL MEMBERSHIP
Full Unlimited Access
$15.00/mo ($180.00/year)
Sale! Only $7.50/ mo. ($90.00/year)
Access to our Website
Access to our Website
Receive Updates and Case Alerts
Receive Updates and Case Alerts
Full access our library of prior case briefs, special updates, and resources
Access our library of prior issues and special updates
Search Capability
Search Capability
Ability to post comments
Ability to post comments
Print/download/save material from our site
Print/download/save material from our site
Direct access to our authors
Direct access to our authors
Annual Statutes and Changes in the law Update (100+ pages)
Annual Statutes and Changes in the law Update (100+ pages)
Annual Miranda Update
Annual Miranda Update
Annual Search & Seizure and Fourth Amendment Update (1000+ pages) Our most comprehensive and popular update! A must have for Judges, prosecutors, and police supervisors
Annual Search & Seizure and Fourth Amendment Update (1000+ pages) Our most comprehensive and popular update! A must have for judges, prosecutors, and police supervisors
KEEP CURRENT PLAN

NEWSLETTER

Enter your email and would like to subscribe to our monthly updates.

Stay informed - subscribe to our newsletter.

Already have an account? Login Here

Sign-up now to access our website. It takes less than one minute, no credit card required

Enter your details below and stay ahead of the curve.

We need a little information about you to approve your subscription. We take your privacy seriously. Don’t worry we never share your information with anyone.

1
Login Detail
2
Profile Detail
Password strength:
Use only if your agency is paying for your subscription
We take your privacy seriously. As detailed in our Privacy Policy, we do not share your information with anyone. You will be able to update your communication preferences at any time. Please contact Legal Updates if you have any questions or need any assistance.
Forgot Password?